Just Released! Order “Waking Up to Climate Change” by George Ropes, and receive 25% Discount. Learn More

HOME          CATEGORIES          OUR TAKE

SCOTUS Poised to Handcuff the EPA

In the wake of reactionary rulings by the Supreme Court that seized a woman’s right to abortion after the Justices had unleashed potentially lethal freedoms to gun owners, one can only shudder at the prospect of the court’s upcoming decision on West Virginia v. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The case aims to weaken the Environmental Protection Agency’s ability to fully take on climate change and global warming.

The case is a power grab by those who want to severely limit the government’s ability to regulate industries and businesses responsible for producing greenhouse gases, the main cause of our  planet getting rapidly hotter and polluting the air that we breath. The main plaintiff is West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey joined by 19 Republican attorneys general. Morrisey represents two coal companies: The North American Coal Corporation, and Westmoreland Mining Holdings, LLC. The coal industry is the country’s second-largest emitter of greenhouse gases.  Morrisey and his team will argue that the EPA has no authority to regulate plant emissions and that power should be given to Congress.

The highly conservative leaning court and its heady lust for power may indeed rule that it’s illegal for federal agencies like the EPA to enforce major decisions without Congress’ authorization. And with our current, plodding and uncertain Congress known to successfully stall any vote on climate change initiatives, their lackluster interest would smother any bill trying to get to the floor aimed at restricting emissions to curb climate change.

There was hope with President Biden’s Build Back Better Act offering $555 billion worth of climate and clean energy provisions. Had it been implemented the scientific community estimated a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions in the U.S. by 43% by 2030. A cooler earth which humanity has a chance to survive.

Protecting the coal industry in Congress is West Virginia Senator Joe Manchin who has made millions of dollars from the low-grade coal supplier Enersystems, run by Manchin’s son, Joseph Manchin. Senator Manchin has consistently blocked federal legislation aimed to usher in a sustainable era using wind, solar and other clean energy to transition away from coal, oil and gas.

About 74 percent of voters are concerned about air and water pollution according to polling  by Data for Progress and Evergreen Action. That includes 79 percent of Independents and 57 percent of Republicans. West Virginia v. EPA puts a section of the Clean Air Act (CAA) under the Justices’ legal microscope. CAA is the landmark air quality legislation passed in 1970 that impacts regulations today. SCOTUS will seek to strip certain provisions from CAA and set a precedent for the future, a future that will prevent the EPA from controlling power plant emissions, an essential regulation to control air and water pollution and reduce greenhouse gases.

If SCOTUS issues such a ruling, it will spell disaster for the earth. Other nations may well follow the U.S. and turn its back on promises made in the 2016 Paris Agreement. Climate change efforts would be set back years if not decades, imperiling the lives of billions and ultimately losing the war to save the planet.

Comment on this article

ClimateYou moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. Abusive, profane, self-promotional, misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected. Moderators are staffed during regular business hours (New York time) and can only accept comments written in English.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.


More Posts Like This


My Take on Climate Change

According to information given on the website Climate.org, there are a number of statistics which are indicative of the current climate condition: For example, carbon dioxide in the Atmosphere — 414 (Carbon Dioxide…).  According to the Climate Portal of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, “Atmospheric CO2 levels of


Youth Activists Triumph in Groundbreaking Climate Trial

A landmark legal decision has overwhelmingly justified every human being’s right to a healthy environment. The huge victory by young climate activists in Montana is a win for young people all over the world whose future will undeniably be shaped by the effects of climate change. The case,


Losing our Coveted Trees to Floods

In the great aftermath of major flooding last week here in the Hudson Valley 30 miles north of New York City, towns and villages are recovering from torrential rains that dumped six to seven inches in an already saturated region. Roads dissolved under water. Streams, lakes and rivers